Beyond BT

Baalei Teshuvah and Other Growth Oriented Jews

The Baal Teshuvah and Israel

Posted on | November 15, 2010 | By Akiva | 4 Comments

Print Friendly

by Reb Akiva of Mystical Paths

As you become interested in Judaism and start reading the tefilot (prayers), you notice reference after reference to Israel. As a Jewish American (order intention) who’s looking to learn more about religion, the constant mentions of Israel are downright confusing.

Learning a bit more it gets even more confusing! Why do we say “moreed hatal” or “mashiv haruach umoreed hageshem” (who makes the dew fall or who brings the wind and rain) at different times of the year which may not match the local weather pattern? Because that’s when it rains or doesn’t rain in Israel!

Sitting back as an American, why am I suddenly expected to be praying about Israel all the time? Isn’t this kind of a political thing? Do I have to instantly become a zionist and supporter of the Israeli government to be religiously Jewish?

It takes some time to learn the proper balance and perspective. That is…Israel is the Holy Land and G-d’s gift to the Jewish people. Judaism is intimately tied up with Israel, such that over half the commandments can ONLY be fulfilled in Israel, every set of prayers and even birkat hamazon (blessings after a meal) mention Israel and the mystical side of Judaism teaches that all our prayers must travel via Israel on their way to the kisay hakavod.

While it is possible to be Jewish and religiously Jewish in any part of the world, Judaism is designed around Israel, Jerusalem, and the Beis HaMikdash (the Holy Temple currently in ruin with a mosque sitting on the site). This is not a political statement, this is religious statement that is a fundamental part of Judaism and Jewishness.

Now how Jews should deal with this in relating to a secular Jewish Israeli government operating a secular Jewish nation-state with a majority Jewish population in PART of the historical and biblical Land of Israel and incorporating Jewish culture and holidays is another question altogether.

But regardless of one’s political position there’s two things that can’t be denied. Judaism and Jewishness is directly tied to the Land of Israel. One cannot deny this without denying the Torah, the Mishnah, the Gemora, the Mishneh Torah and the Shulchan Aruch.

And the current State of Israel has a whole lot of Jews living there. Just about 1/2 the Jews of the world currently live in Israel, with Jews from 63 different countries making their home there. The threats to the State of Israel are existential, meaning life and death, existence or genocidal slaughter.

So one quickly learns as a religious Jew that the Land of Israel involves every Jew and every Jew’s essence of Judaism. And while the State of Israel as a political entity is a separate matter, the threats to the Jews living there make it a matter of Ahavas Yisroel (love of your fellow) to support their safety.

Be Sociable, Share!

Comments

4 Responses to “The Baal Teshuvah and Israel”

  1. AMR
    November 16th, 2010 @ 7:47 am

    Akiva

    I am trying to understand the point of this post as it is unclear to me.

  2. Menachem Lipkin
    November 16th, 2010 @ 10:49 am

    I think he mentioned the “political entity” phrase at least one too many times. We get it, but it starts to sound like the way our enemies (both Jewish and non-Jewish) refer to Israel as the “Zionist entity”. For those of who see the hand of God in the founding of the state it’s a tad condescending.

    I think his intent was good, Jews need to focus on Israel both because it’s the center of our religion and because lots of us live here. Of course he didn’t make the next logical step in saying that while its possible to live a Jewish life outside of Israel, it’s far from the ideal.

  3. squarepeg613
    November 16th, 2010 @ 3:06 pm

    Great article! My best friend kept pointing things like this out to me in college, and eventually got me to make Aliyah. :-)

  4. AMR
    November 17th, 2010 @ 4:31 am

    I guess a reason is not forthcoming

    It is however pertinent to note that in the next 5 or so years Israel will become the seat of the majority of the Jewish population of the world, an important halachic event in and of itself.

    This will happen in one of three places:

    1) in a hospital in Israel – Hopefully
    2) in a plane over the Atlantic toward Israel – also hopeful
    3) in a church in the US – probable

    AMR

Leave a Reply





  • RSS Shul Politics

  • Popular Posts

  • Advisors

    Rabbi Yakov Horowitz (Monsey)
    Rabbi Herschel Welcher (Kew Gardens Hills)

    Project Administrators

    Mark Frankel (Kew Gardens Hills)
    David Linn (Kew Gardens Hills)

    Current Contributors

    Email us at beyondbt@gmail.com if you would like to contribute

    Azriela Jaffe (Highland Park, NJ)
    Bracha Goetz (Baltimore, MA)
    Neil Harris (Chicago)
    Rabbi Yonason Goldson (St. Louis)
    Ron Coleman (Passaic)
    Guest Contributors

    Past Contributors

    Akiva (Eretz Yisroel)
    Aliza Hausman (Bronx, NY)
    Anxious Ima (Eretz Yisroel)
    Aryeh Leib Ecker (Kew Gardens Hills)
    A Simple Jew (United States)
    Avrahom-Moishe Erlenwein (Postville, Iowa)
    Belle (New Jersey)
    Bob Miller (Indianapolis, IN)
    Chava Ashkenazi (Ramat Bet Shemesh)
    Daniel Rosenthal (Passaic)
    David Kirschner (Kew Gardens Hills)
    Dixie Yid (The South)
    Eliahu Levenson (Toronto)
    Fern (California)
    Frumhouse (Chicago)
    Ilanit Meckley (Houston)
    Jewish Deaf Motorcycle Dad (Virginia)
    Judy Resnick (Far Rockaway)
    Leah Levenson (Toronto)
    Katrin (Modiin)
    Kressel Housman (Monsey)
    Maya (New York City)
    Melech (Passaic)
    Menachem Lipkin (Bet Shemesh)
    Meyer (Atlanta)
    Michael Goodheart (Jerusalem)
    Michael Gros (Ramat Beit Shemesh)
    Michoel (Baltimore)
    Ora (Jerusalem)
    Phyllis (Dallas)
    Rabbi Alter Klein (Bet Shemesh)
    Rabbi David Schallheim (Jerusalem)
    Rabbi Daniel Travis (Har Nof)
    Rabbi Label Lam (Monsey)
    Rabbi Lazer Brody (Ashdod)
    Rabbi Max Weiman (St. Louis)
    Rabbi Mayer Schiller (New Square)
    Rabbi Moshe Zionce (Toronto)
    Rabbi Shlomo Goldberg (Los Angeles)
    Rabbi Zev Kahn (Chicago)
    Rachel Adler (U Penn)
    Rebecca Weiser (U Texas)
    Rivkah (Baltimore)
    Ross Kryger (TriState Area)
    Shayna (Monsey)
    Shirah Shuraqui (Toronto)
    Shoshana (Passaic)
    Shoshanna Silcove (Melbourne)
    Simon Synett (Ramat Beit Shemesh)
    Steve Brizel (Kew Gardens Hills)
    Susanne Goldstone (Washington Heights)
    William Kolbrener (East Coast)
    Yaakov Astor (Monsey)
    Yaakov Eric Ackland (East Coast)

  • Categories

  • S.M.